Stigma from inside the community lands differently from stigma outside it. Partly because it comes from people who share the history, partly because these are the spaces you cannot simply avoid, and partly because the expectation of safety makes the surprise worse.
What does it look like?
Profiles stating a status requirement. The word clean used to mean negative. Being dropped from a conversation the moment you disclose. Assumptions about how you acquired it. Being told you should have known better. Gossip about someone's status, which is one of the more damaging things that happens in small scenes.
Why is the word clean the problem?
Because it makes everyone else dirty, and because it describes something nobody can verify about themselves. Most infections cause nothing noticeable, so a person calling themselves clean is reporting a belief rather than a fact. Asking when someone last tested achieves what they actually wanted.
What is usually behind it?
Information from twenty years ago, and fear. A great many people have never been told that a sustained undetectable viral load means HIV is not transmitted sexually, and are reacting to a picture that stopped being accurate long ago. That is not an excuse for the behaviour and it does explain why the reaction is so disproportionate.
How do you respond?
Once, with the facts, and then stop. A short reply and a link to a clinical source works better than an argument, since people absorb information on their own more readily than while defending a position. Extended debate turns into a conversation in which you make the case for your own acceptability, which is a demoralising place to spend an evening.
What if someone is spreading it around?
Different and more serious. Passing on someone's status without their agreement is a significant breach, and it is one of the main reasons people do not disclose at all. If it is happening to you, it is worth addressing directly, and where it comes with harassment it may be a matter for Galop or the police.
Does it help to say something as a bystander?
More than anything else on this page. Profiles stating exclusions and casual use of the word clean persist largely because nobody who is not affected ever comments. Telling a friend that a line in their profile is doing something they probably did not intend is a small, awkward and disproportionately useful act.
What about choosing where you spend time?
Legitimate rather than a retreat. Some venues, groups and apps are noticeably better than others, and reducing exposure is a practical response when the cumulative effect is wearing you down. Sports clubs, choirs and social groups tend to be considerably better on this than apps.
Does it get better?
Unevenly. Attitudes among younger men have shifted more than among older ones, and awareness of undetectable status is far higher than it was even five years ago. The experience of individual rejection remains common, which is not the same as nothing changing.
What helps most?
Other people who have had it. Peer support through Terrence Higgins Trust or Positively UK puts you in contact with people who have handled these conversations many times, and their practical advice is better than anything written down. It also addresses the isolation, which is usually the larger problem.
What is worth holding onto
Someone rejecting a category has not made a judgement about you, because they have not looked. That is worse in one way and considerably less personal in another.
What about within a relationship?
Harder, because there is no leaving the conversation. A partner repeatedly expressing anxiety about a status that poses no transmission risk is asking you to manage something that is theirs. Attending a clinic appointment together, where a clinician explains it, resolves more of these than months of discussion at home.
Does calling it out work?
Occasionally, and it depends on the setting. A private message to someone you know lands better than a public exchange, which tends to entrench positions. Neither is obligatory.