Both settings involve group sex and they differ in ways that matter. A commercial venue has staff, rules and someone responsible for the premises. A private party has whoever is hosting and whatever they have decided. Neither is inherently safer, and knowing which you are in changes what you should bring and what you can rely on.
What venues provide
Usually condoms and lubricant, sometimes free through local sexual health commissioning. Staff on the premises who can call an ambulance, intervene in a problem or ask someone to leave. Lighting and layout designed for the purpose. Cleaning between sessions. Some run health promotion or on-site testing in partnership with local services, which is worth asking about.
What venues do not provide
Supervision of what happens between people. Staff are not monitoring individual encounters, and consent in dark rooms and cubicles depends on the same conventions as anywhere else: moving towards someone, moving away, and treating ambiguity as a stop rather than a yes.
What private parties depend on
The host, entirely. A well-run private event has house rules stated in advance, supplies available, someone sober enough to notice problems and a clear sense of who is welcome. A poorly run one has none of those, and there is nobody to escalate to if something goes wrong.
What is harder at a private party?
Leaving, if it is somewhere unfamiliar and transport is difficult. Getting help, if nobody is in a state to call for it. Knowing who is present, since guest lists at private events are frequently informal. And having any recourse afterwards, since there is no organisation to complain to.
What is easier at a private party?
Knowing who is there, if it is a group you already know. Setting expectations beforehand, because there is usually a conversation rather than a door policy. Privacy, since a venue is a public place you might be seen entering.
What about anonymity?
Venues are more anonymous in the encounter and less anonymous in attendance. Private parties are usually the reverse. This matters for partner notification: if you are diagnosed with something, a clinic can often work with a profile name or a party group, and complete anonymity makes notification impossible.
What should you bring to either?
Your own lubricant in your own container, condoms in the width that fits you, gloves if relevant, your medication dose, and a way home. Venue supplies are a backup rather than a plan, and sachets in particular tend to be too small for anal sex.
How do you judge a venue?
Whether supplies are actually available and stocked. Whether it is clean. Whether staff are visible and approachable. Whether there are stated rules and any sign they are enforced. Whether there is somewhere to put your things securely. These are ordinary standards and a venue failing them is failing at the basics.
What about drugs?
Present in both settings to varying degrees. Venues generally prohibit them formally and vary in practice. The relevant point is that either setting can leave someone unwell and unnoticed, and knowing where staff are in a venue, or who is sober at a party, is worth establishing early.
What about outdoor and public settings?
A third category with its own considerations: no supplies, no staff, no lighting and the possibility of being disturbed. Take everything you need, tell someone where you are going, and be aware that leaving quickly may matter more than at either of the other settings.
Which should you choose?
Whichever suits what you want, with the preparation adjusted accordingly. A private party asks more of you because there is less around you.
What about cost and time?
Venues charge entry and often run to fixed hours, which imposes a natural end. Private parties have no closing time, which is one reason they run into long weekends and the fatigue that comes with them. Knowing roughly when something will end is worth asking about.
Which is better for someone new to this?
Usually a venue, because there are staff, stated rules, an exit and no obligation to anyone. You can arrive, look around and leave without it being a social event you have to extract yourself from.